Beyond Completion: Defining Success in Online Higher Education

Success in Online Higher Education Isn’t Always Defined by Degree Completion

The debate about the success of online higher education continues to resurface. Traditional institutions and higher education publications often fuel this debate. They seem determined to cast online learning in a negative light. One such article is Liam Knox’s, “Online Degrees Out of Reach” recently published by Inside Higher Education. I have been an educator involved in the online learning landscape for over a decade. I feel compelled to tackle some of the persistent misconceptions.

Returning students often prefer the flexibility of online education

image provided by freepik.com
Motherhood can be a barrier to traditional classrooms

image generated by shurkin_son at freekpik.com

Equity and Access Can Lead to Success in Online Higher Education

Firstly, the data cited in these critiques often neglect crucial contextual factors. These include open enrollment policies, which welcome students from a variety of educational backgrounds. For example, these policies often admit those with prior unsuccessful attempts at higher education as well as limited financial resources. Unlike traditional institutions, these policies prevent online institutions from limiting student populations to only those they expect to succeed. Accessibility, is an important part of the mission of online education. However, it can impact completion rates because it serves student populations with unique challenges and needs.  

Challenges to Success in Online Education for Non-Traditional Students

Furthermore, a direct comparison between completion rates at traditional institutions and online programs is inherently flawed. Many students enrolled in online programs are non-traditional learners, juggling full-time employment, family responsibilities, and often, military service. These factors, therefore, significantly impact their ability to pursue education in a traditional, time-constrained manner.  

Student Definitions of Success in Online Courses

It is crucial to acknowledge that the value of education extends beyond degree completion. Online programs offer flexible learning opportunities. They are beneficial for individuals who may not have access to traditional campuses. They also offer the needed flexibility to balance education with other life demands. These programs offer a valuable pathway to upward mobility. They aid skill development and personal enrichment for a significant segment of the population.  

Eliminating the Misconception of Online Learning Quality

Further, the assertion that online education is somehow inferior to traditional instruction is both inaccurate and deeply concerning. Faculty at online institutions are dedicated educators who employ innovative teaching methodologies, foster engaging learning environments, and prioritize student success. Indeed, to suggest otherwise is a disservice to the hard work and dedication of these educators. Moreover, it also diminishes the transformative impact they have on their students.  

Call for a More Holistic Evaluation

Moving forward, a more nuanced understanding of online higher education is essential. We need to move away from simplistic metrics like completion rates. We must also explore the unique value proposition of these programs more deeply. It demands a recognition of the diverse student populations served. We must also understand the complex factors influencing their educational journeys. Additionally, we must acknowledge the dedication and expertise of online faculty. Only then can we appreciate how online education expands access to higher education. It empowers learners from diverse backgrounds.

Stephanie McConnell contributed to this article.

Search

Popular Posts

  • Why Now? Gen-Z Is Transforming Education and We Must Adjust
    Why Now? Gen-Z Is Transforming Education and We Must Adjust

    Why We Must Change Now? Higher education has existed since ancient times. In much of that time, it was limited to those studying religious doctrine or the very wealthy. In the 20th century, access to higher education became more widespread across the globe. As demonstrated by Vera Korhonen for Statistia, by the end of the…

  • Discussion Forums: How To Ensure Their Value

    Why Use Discussion Forums? We know that one of the most important keys to successful asynchronous learning is instructor presence (Mandau & Van Berg 2023).  Students want to know that their instructors care about their success, and that they are “there” in the course. We can do this most efficiently in class discussion forums. Therefore, let’s…

  • Reaching Gen-Z Students in Higher Education – Try Some New Strategies
    Reaching Gen-Z Students in Higher Education – Try Some New Strategies

    Generation-Z students (Gen-Z), those born between 1997-2010, are the most technologically advanced generation of our lifetimes.  They are digital natives, who have accessed technology from a young age.  It is, therefore, unsurprising that they are enrolling increasingly in online, higher education programs.  Reaching Gen-Z, then, will become a critical skill for those teaching in higher…